P3D Re: Window Violations

[fj834@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (Dr. George A. Themelis)]

>> Does anyone have an example of intentionally violating the window (as
>> opposed to coming through the window) for a specific effect.
>
>I don't think I have any, but I have seen a DrT slide that uses a
>window violation to great effect.  He can describe it for us, or
>with his permission I can.

You have my blessing Paul! (I don't know which slide you are refering to.)

But I was thinking that the bottom or top side violations are much
easier to deal with and some time can be used for effect, for example
when you have a lake or sea scene with water very close to the camera 
and you let the water "flow" out of the screen and into the room.

>Vertical edge violations are far more problematic than horizontal
>edge violations.

Yes, indeed.

>For vertical edge violations, you might choose to keep the violation
>rather than cause some other ill effect like too much far point
>separation when the chips are pushed farther apart. 

Right on!

Thanks for the careful in-depth discussion of this issue!

George Themelis


------------------------------