[photo-3d] Bob logic

[L <jet_lk@xxxxxxxxx>]

Herbert/Bob wrote:

Vision is a motion picture stock, and is not designed
for still use. If
you are going to shoot with color negatives, the best
thing to do is 
use
film designed for that use. My suggestion is to only
use Vision if you
are shooting 35mm motion pictures.

Bob
----------

Bob, I don't mean to get down on you here.  I just
want to point out a few things.

Bob, do you realize that a still camera be it an SLR
or what ever was designed for still shots, but have
been used very successfully in movies MANY times (such
as The Matrix".  And of course those one lens cameras
weren't designed for 3-D use iether, but many of us
used them for that all the time.

Just because something wasn't designed for something
doesn't mean it can't be used for it.  You seem to
keep giving advice to people on this list on subjects
that you know little from experience, and a lot from
assumption.  I am not asking you to stop, as it is not
my place.  I just find it bothersome that you keep
giving wrong advice based on guesses, and are probably
confusing people.  I am sure you have an extensive
background in photography, but if haven't actually
tried something, why tell people it is no good.  That
doesn't really help anyone.  There are more than
enough people on this list that have tried just about
every type of film, and every camera out there to
answer from experience.

I decided that I don't like Kodachrome as much as
provia 100F by actually shooting many rolls of similar
subjects within similar conditions and comparing them.
 I have seen the new vision film used for stereo
slides, and even though it is not as good as shooting
real slide film, it isn't bad.  The person asked what
to do with an already shot roll of neg film.  It
really is his only affordable choice.  Telling him not
to use it because it wasn't meant for that is silly. 
Dale and some other labs make slides from negs for
still shots by the tens of thousands a week.  It does
work.

Lincoln

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Send instant messages & get email alerts with Yahoo! Messenger.
http://im.yahoo.com/