T3D Re: Deering spreadsheet

[Tom Deering <tmd@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

>How many times am I going to tell you that I don't use the 1/30 rule for
>macros.  I don't use any rule!  The only thing I did not like from the
>very start is your attitude towards the 1/30.  In your pages you are using
>the phrase "it does not work".  What does that mean?  Define "it works".
>In your graphs you label "1/30 rule" and MAOFD solutions "real math".
>1/30 is math too.  Does "real" mean more complicated?  More correct?


I asked yesterday why George would pick apart a spreadsheet he clearly will
never use.  The above paragraph shows he is only interested in perpetuating
a long angry disagreement over the 1/30 guestimate.  It's a shame, everyone
else here is so nice.

To reiterate my answer to George's repeated attacks, the "M" in MAOFD
stands for "maximum."  It does not stand for "required".

Rather than go through this all again, perhaps George will tell us what he
thinks the 1/30 thing does?  I think that will tell the tale.

Cheers,

Tom



------------------------------