Judging/voting criteria for 3D photography

[Peter Davis <pdavis@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

All this talk of voting in the 3d@xxxxxx, etc. had gotten me thinking about
what judges look for, and what people vote for in 3D photography.  Is it
the 3D-ness of the picture (the "in your face"-ness), or is it the use
of 3D in overall composition, or is it how well the picture recreates
the experience of being there, or ...

I'm sure different people have different criteria, but are there any
guidelines in competitions, or is it just "vote for whatever grabs
you?"

I have not been interested in entering any of my work because I
consider most of it fairly personal.  Not that it's private, but that
I think it appeals to me both because it recreates an experience I
enjoyed, and because I enjoyed the taking of the picture.  I think
some of them are visually striking, but I don't expect them to have
the same impact on others as they do on me.

Thanks.
-pd

--------
Peter Davis                    "Education is not the             617/873-4145
BBN Educational Technologies    filling of a pail, but      FAX: 617/873-2455
70 Fawcett Street               the lighting of a fire."       pdavis@xxxxxxx
Cambridge, MA 02138                     -- W. B. Yeats

        URL:  http://copernicus.bbn.com/people/PDavis/


------------------------------

End of PHOTO-3D Digest 11
*************************