Re: Where is the window - proposed experiment

[P3D Paul Talbot <ptww@xxxxxxxxx>]

Larry Berlin proposes solving the "where is the window question"
with a special test image:

> I propose you use a picture with some kind of meaningful measurement
> within it. The window is wherever you place it, and you should be
> able to identify precisely where it is according to the measurements
> within the image itself.

That sounds true enough with respect to the relationship between the
window and the objects in the scene.  But the difference of opinion
has been about how far the window appears to be from the observer.
This appears to be very subjective and open to several different
interpretations.  Or perhaps I should say two interpretations:
1) DrT's and 2) everyone else's.  ;) ;) ;) ;) ;)

Paul Talbot


------------------------------