Re: Window reversal

[P3D Dr. George A. Themelis <DrT-3d@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Somehow communication has become a bit difficult lately...

Greg Wageman writes:

>With all due respect to the good Doctor, I don't think that's what Bill
>was describing at all.  To me it sounded more like the situation that
>results when you photograph a subject which is closer than the 7-foot
>window with a Realist. 

That's "window violation" assuming that this object intercepts
the edges of the window.

I said the same thing but in my own words and more general.  
I said the window is placed past objects that intercept it.  
This is "window violation" and you describe one example of
it, window at 7 feet and closest object at 5.  So the window
is past (counting from the camera) an object that intercepts it.
Another case is to have the window at 20 feet and the closest
object at 10.  Or, have the window at infinity or even past
infinity.  We've seen examples like that in old stereo views.
And that's what Bill is describing by saying which eye sees
more in which side.

-- George Themelis


------------------------------