P3D Window Violations

["Andrea Blair" <asblair@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

>>>>Bob Maxey questions: You mentioned that there were Window 
violations. What does a slide have to do to violate the Stereo Window? 
Just curious. For me, I love to violate the window. I love stereo where 
as much as possible comes thorough the Stereo Window, But that is just 
me.<<<<

>>Someone else wrote: You won't break or violate the window just
by having an object stick through the center of the (wide-open)
window.  But you should not try to stick objects through the window
frame (especially the vertical portions).<<

>>>>Bob Maxey then writes: But for me, that is what I like. I understand 
some do not like this, but I shoot for me.<<<<

>>Then Dr. T writes: RM, I don't think you understand the concept of the 
stereo window. Or the violation of it.<<

>>>>Bob Maxey then writes: Actually, RM (With an Indigent Stare) 
understands it very well indeed. I think from reading various posts 
about the subject, that others might not. Or at least might have a 
different idea. That is why I asked the question.<<<<

>>>>Bob Maxey goes on to define: If an object touches or "Breaks" the 
frame, parts of the object will appear in front of the window, confusing 
the viewer. A hand holding an object that does not touch the frame comes 
out of the window, and everything looks good unless part of the object 
touches the frame. <snip> If you desire to have some objects "coming at 
you", through the window, it is imperative that anything located at the 
edge of the slide mount does not protrude through the window.<<<<

Bob, you obviously know your stuff, so I am assuming from your original 
comments of "I love to violate the window (see top quote)"  and "but for 
me, that is what I like (see second quote)" that you actually like to 
disrupt people's brains when they view your images by violating the 
window (frame) intentionally? I originally thought you enjoyed the 
"coming through the window" effect, as I do, but I guess I was wrong. My 
apologies if my elementary example offended you in any way. Perhaps I am 
the one who is missing something here?

Andrea Blair
asblair@xxxxxxxxxxx

______________________________________________________
Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com


------------------------------